Send Us

Vincent-zhong@greatwin-test.com
     Vincent-zhong@gfmachine.com  
 0086-0769-82767811 / 0086-13929200954
Home » News » News » Industry » Sustainable Foams vs. Mechanical Durability: Calibrating Physical Testing Workflows for Eco-Friendly Footwear

Sustainable Foams vs. Mechanical Durability: Calibrating Physical Testing Workflows for Eco-Friendly Footwear

Views: 0     Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2026-11-19      Origin: Site

Inquire

facebook sharing button
twitter sharing button
line sharing button
wechat sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
sharethis sharing button

A new foam can look promising on a material data sheet: it may contain recycled or bio-based content and offer the low weight a footwear brand is looking for. But before it reaches a midsole or insole, there is another question to answer: how will it perform through repeated use?

For footwear manufacturers, introducing an alternative foam means checking more than a single strength or density value. The material needs to fit the intended product, remain consistent between batches and perform acceptably after compression, bending and wear.

A well-planned physical testing workflow helps teams compare new formulations with an existing material and identify trade-offs early—before a production change becomes a customer complaint.

Start With the Job the Foam Needs to Do

Not all footwear foams serve the same purpose. A midsole material may be selected for cushioning and weight, while an insole may need a different balance of softness, recovery and comfort. A protective shoe component may have additional requirements set by a customer or applicable standard.

Before testing, define the intended application and choose a suitable reference material. If a manufacturer is replacing a conventional foam with a formulation containing recycled content, testing both materials under the same conditions provides a more useful comparison than reviewing their supplier data sheets in isolation.

The question is not simply whether the new foam is “strong enough.” It is whether its combination of properties meets the needs of that particular shoe.

Density: A Starting Point for Comparing Foams

Density matters because it affects material weight and can help quality teams identify variation between batches. If two samples from the same formulation have noticeably different densities, the team has a reason to investigate the material or production process before looking at other test results.

For cellular plastics and rubbers, ISO 845 describes methods for determining apparent density. When a molded foam has a surface skin, the standard distinguishes between overall and core density. This distinction matters: a specimen cut from the inside of a molded part may not give the same result as a piece that includes the skin.

A useful test record should state where the sample was taken, whether the skin was retained and how the specimen was prepared. Those details make later comparisons more meaningful.

Density alone does not establish durability. Two foams with similar densities can respond differently to tension or compression, so it should be considered alongside other physical properties.

11.19new.png

Tensile Testing: Understanding Strength and Elongation

Tensile testing measures how a specimen responds as it is pulled. For a footwear development team, tensile strength and elongation at break can help compare a new foam with a reference material or identify changes between batches.

ISO 1798 covers the determination of tensile strength and elongation at break for flexible cellular polymeric materials. The method selected should suit the material being tested and the specification agreed with the buyer.

Great Win’s GW-011A Universal Testing Machine is designed for tests including tension and compression on materials such as foam, rubber and plastics. The correct load range, grips and specimen preparation should be selected for the material and test method.

When reviewing results, it is also useful to note where the specimen broke and whether the break appeared consistent across samples. An unexpected result may reflect a material issue, but specimen preparation, gripping or measurement should be checked before drawing a conclusion.

Compression Set: What Happens After the Load Is Removed?

Cushioning materials are repeatedly compressed in use. A compression set test looks at how much permanent deformation remains after a specimen has been compressed and allowed to recover under specified conditions.

For applicable materials, ISO 1856 sets out methods for determining compression set. Its scope covers latex and polyurethane foams of the specified thickness; it should not be assumed to apply to every foam used in footwear.

Compression set is useful when comparing formulations, particularly when weight reduction or a change in ingredients is being considered. It is one part of the assessment, however, and should not be treated as a direct prediction of how long a finished shoe will remain comfortable.

Depending on the product, a test plan may also include repeated compression or other fatigue testing. These tests answer different questions and should be selected to match the intended application.

11.19 new1.png

Flexing and Wear: Looking Beyond the Foam Specimen

A foam can perform well as a standalone specimen but behave differently once it is part of a shoe. Shape, thickness, bonding and the surrounding materials all influence how a component moves.

Flex testing can help teams investigate cracking or damage in sole materials and finished footwear. Great Win offers the GW-003 Outsoles Flexing Testing Machine for assessing repeated bending damage in sole materials, and the GW-009C Shoe Flexing Testing Machine for examining shoes under repeated flexing.

The test method should match the question being asked. Testing a sheet of foam, a molded sole and a completed shoe can provide different—and complementary—information.

Building a Testing Workflow Your Team Can Repeat

When comparing conventional and alternative materials, consistency in the workflow matters as much as the list of tests. A practical approach is to:

  1. Define the application and acceptance criteria. Agree on the properties that matter for the component and the requirements set by the customer or relevant standard.

  2. Prepare comparable specimens. Record the source, dimensions, orientation and any molded skin, following the selected method.

  3. Control conditioning and test conditions. Keep preparation, environment and test settings consistent so that results can be compared.

  4. Check measurement equipment. Verify that the balance, dimensional measuring tools and testing machine are suitable for the range being measured and maintained or calibrated as required.

  5. Review the full set of results. Compare density, tensile properties and compression behavior together, then consider component or whole-shoe tests where appropriate.

  6. Keep traceable records. Link each result to the material formulation, batch, specimen, equipment and test method.

If a new foam performs differently from the reference, the result gives the development team a starting point for discussion. It may lead to a formulation adjustment, a design change or a decision to use the material in a different component.

Assessing Performance Alongside Environmental Claims

Recycled or bio-based content can be an important part of a material strategy, but physical testing alone does not establish a material’s overall environmental impact. Sourcing, manufacturing, transport, product life and end-of-life options also need to be considered when making sustainability claims.

What physical testing can do is provide evidence about the properties that matter to the product. That evidence helps manufacturers assess whether an alternative foam meets their performance requirements and where further development is needed.

If you are reviewing foam materials or planning a footwear testing workflow, explore Great Win’s tensile testing equipment or contact Vincent-zhong@greatwin-test.com to discuss your application.

GREAT WIN
Phone:
0086-0769-82767811
0086-13929200954
Address:
A6,Huazhi high-tech park,Yongqing Village,Daojiao Town,Dongguan City,Guangdong Province , China
About Us
Great Win Testing Machine CO. Ltd was set up in 1999, it has been over 20 years' history in the field of professional experience for lab testing instrument such as Footwear Testing Equipment, Leather Testing Equipment, Textile Testing Equipment, Toy Testing ...
Subscribe
 Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest news.

© 2021 Great Win Testing Machine CO. Ltd All rights reserved. Technology By Leadong.com | Sitemap